The Notre Dame-BYU debate that BYU fans are completely WRONG about!

Notre Dame Fighting Irish - A to Z Sports
•September 24th, 2026
DESCRIPTION
Download the Kalshi app and use code ATOZ to get $20 when you trade $20. Kalshi. Trade on anything.
Sign up today: http://kalshi.com/r/ATOZ
Sponsor Disclosure: Kalshi: 18+ only. Restrictions and eligibility requirements apply. Event contract trading involves risk and may not be suitable for all investors. Kalshi products are not available in all jurisdictions. Prices, values, and available markets may differ from those mentioned. For more information see kalshi.com/regulatory.
The BYU vs Notre Dame football matchup is still weeks away, but the debate between the two fan bases has already started.
The biggest question:
How many BYU defenders would actually start for Notre Dame?
After a viral discussion on social media about the talent level of BYU's defense compared to Notre Dame's defense, Ryan Roberts breaks down the individual players and explains which Cougars defenders could realistically earn starting jobs for the Fighting Irish.
The answer?
Ryan believes there are only one or two BYU defenders who would legitimately start for Notre Dame.
The first is linebacker Cade Uluave
Uluave transferred to BYU after earning All-ACC recognition at Cal and has quickly become one of the best linebackers in college football. Ryan believes he is a legitimate difference-maker and would likely start alongside Kyngstonn Viliamu-Asa for Notre Dame.
The other player with a realistic argument is cornerback Evan Johnson.
Johnson is an excellent player who could compete for a starting role at outside corner or potentially challenge for the nickel position. Ryan does not believe he would replace Leonard Moore, but believes there is a legitimate conversation about where Johnson fits in Notre Dame's secondary.
Beyond those two players, Ryan believes the gap is much larger than some BYU fans are suggesting.
Keanu Tanuvasa is a talented defensive tackle, but Ryan views him as more of a rotational player rather than someone who would immediately take over a starting job at Notre Dame.
Isaiah Glasker has impressive statistics and production, but Ryan believes Notre Dame's linebacker depth would prevent him from becoming a starter.
BYU safety Tanner Wall is a good player, but Ryan does not believe he would start over Notre Dame's safety group of Adon Shuler, Brauntae Johnson and Luke Talich.
Tausili Akana is another talented edge rusher, but Ryan believes Notre Dame's defensive line rotation with players like Boubacar Traore, Bryce Young, Keon Keeley and Rodney Dunham would prevent him from becoming a starter.
This conversation is not meant to disrespect BYU.
Ryan believes BYU has a talented roster, a strong coaching staff and several players who could help Notre Dame. He specifically highlights LJ Martin as a player he believes would immediately become Notre Dame's RB1.
But when comparing the two defenses, Ryan believes Notre Dame still has the deeper and more talented unit.
The Fighting Irish secondary, in particular, may be the deepest group Notre Dame has had in South Bend in a very long time.
So who is right?
Would multiple BYU defenders actually start for Notre Dame? Or is the gap between the two defenses bigger than some fans believe?
Ryan Roberts breaks down the BYU vs Notre Dame defensive talent debate.
Subscribe for Notre Dame Fighting Irish football news, recruiting updates, transfer portal coverage, game previews, player evaluations and year-round college football content.
#NotreDame #NotreDameFootball #BYUFootball #FightingIrish #CollegeFootball
*****
Make A to Z Sports your preferred source on Google: https://google.com/preferences/source?q=atozsports.com
Play A to Z Sports Daily Games: https://atozsports.com/games
For More Notre Dame coverage follow us here:
https://atozsports.com/college-football/notre-dame-fighting-irish-news/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/NotreDameFans4Life
Twitter: https://x.com/AtoZSportsNFL
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/atozsportsnotredame/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@notredame.atozsports
****
0:00 BYU vs Notre Dame Defensive Debate
1:05 Why This Became A Viral Conversation
3:00 Would BYU Have 5-6 Starters At Notre Dame?
5:45 Cade Uluave Is The Clear Answer
7:00 Evan Johnson Has A Real Argument
8:00 Keanu Vasa Debate
9:20 Isaiah Glasker Debate
10:30 BYU Safety vs Notre Dame Safety
11:30 BYU Edge Rushers vs Notre Dame
13:00 Final Answer: How Many Would Start?
#notredame #notredamefightingirish #notredamefootball

Never miss a video from Notre Dame Fighting Irish - A to Z Sports
Subscribe to get notified when new content drops.